The red-hot popularity of trucks and SUVs has been going on for so long that Beyondnice Auction Editor Andrew Newton has resorted to using a nautical analogy to explain it: “High tide raises all boats.”
High tide indeed. It’s more like a tsunami.
Two generations of Chevrolet C/K Series trucks (1960–66 and 1973–87) remain tied for the No. 1 spot in the newest Beyondnice Vehicle Rating, which tracks vehicles’ performance relative to the rest of the collector vehicle market. And just when it seemed we’d seen everything, the top 10 placeholders are trucks and SUVs, while another is tied for 11th. Fourteen of the Top 25 are trucks and SUVs.
“It’s one large segment of the market that has consistently seen broad value and interest growth,” Newton says. “Since trucks were cheap for a long time, they’ve had plenty of room to grow, and even as they’ve gotten pricier they remain affordable for the most part. I think that’s why the growth has been sustained.”
The Beyondnice Vehicle Rating is based on a 0–100 scale. A 50-point rating indicates that a vehicle is keeping pace with the market overall. Ratings above 50 indicate above-average appreciation, while vehicles below a 50-point rating are lagging behind the market. The rating is data driven and takes into account the number of vehicles insured and quoted through Beyondnice, along with auction activity and private sales results. The HVR is not an indicator of future collectability.
The top four vehicles are identical to the last HVR. The 1960–66 and 1973–87 Chevrolet C/K Series trucks each have 97 points, followed by the 1966–77 Ford Bronco with 96 and 1955–59 Chevrolet trucks with 95.
Five vehicles are tied for fifth with 94 points apiece: 1946–55 GMC New Design Series pickups, 1947–55 Chevrolet 3100 trucks, 1955–83 Jeep CJ-5, 1967–72 Chevrolet Suburban, and 1973–87 GMC C/K Series pickups. The 1973–91 Chevrolet C/K Blazer is 10th with 93 points, and the 1973–91 Suburban is tied for 11th with 92.
The first four passenger vehicles are all Japanese sports cars. The 1986–92 and 1993– 98 editions of the Toyota Supra broke into the Top 25 the last time around and remain strong, tied for 11th with 92 points. They are followed by the 1992–2002 Mazda RX-7 (91) and 1977–81 Toyota Celica (90). The 1984–89 Toyota MR2, eighth last time, slipped slightly but still carries a solid 78-point total.
“Japanese cars have been getting more attention for several reasons,” Newton says. “They’re typically newer than most vehicles we tend to think of as ‘classics,’ but many are still old enough for nostalgia to kick in. A lot of the neat cars that were coming out when Gen Xers and Millennials were growing up were Japanese. Buyers seem to be placing a higher priority on reliability in a collector car, and the Japanese cars certainly have that going for them when well cared for.”
The top-ranked American car is the 2004–06 Pontiac GTO, which is tied for 16th (89), primarily due to high quoting activity and a rise in Beyondnice Price Guide values.
The most expensive car in the Top 25 is the 16th-place 1986–92 BMW M3, which carries an average HPG value of $63,600 in #3 (Good) condition. The average value of a vehicle in the Top 25 is $15,232. Toss out the BMW M3 and the average value falls to $13,217. Affordability plays a key role, as 16 of the Top 25 vehicles carry an average value of less than $15k.